The duhem-quine thesis and underdetermination

It is this structure that Duhem invokes when he says: EET has generated much philosophical discussion. He says in no uncertain terms that experimental theory in physics is not the same as in fields like physiology and certain branches of chemistry.

Confirmation holism

In the sections that follow we will seek to clearly characterize and distinguish the various forms of both holist and contrastive underdetermination that have been suggested to arise in scientific contexts noting some important connections between them along the wayassess the strength and significance of the heterogeneous argumentative considerations offered in support of and against them, and consider just which forms of underdetermination pose genuinely consequential challenges for scientific inquiry.

What does it show? One way to see why not is to consider an analogy that champions of contrastive underdetermination have sometimes used to support their case. In any case, according to recent externalist-reliabilist theories of justification, belief in theory is justified if induction is reliable; and there is no argument that it is not.

Both sections are organized chronologically.

Underdetermination of Scientific Theory

Decline and Obsolescence of Logical Empiricism: It is just that mathematics and the hypothesis that the physical world exists both have pragmatic value, where Zeus does not. In his last work, La science allemande, mostly a work of wartime propaganda, Duhem added a third kind of mind to his original two, namely, the German mind.

On a similar principle in modern times a prevalent view is that extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proof. If inductive scepticism is set aside, inductive underdetermination must relate to problems with the theory of confirmation.

See also Confirmation Theory ; Scientific Realism. He did not include at all a priori disciplines such as logic and mathematics within the theoretical groups in physics, since they cannot be tested. Therefore, if a physicist is given only an equation, he is not taught anything.

This is the first book devoted to a defence of Quine's indeterminacy of translation doctrine. Let us call the first deductive underdetermination and the second inductive or ampliative underdetermination.

Medieval thought and early modern science are judged to be different in kind as well as in content. Stanfordsuggests that these efforts to prove that all our theories must have empirical equivalents fall roughly but reliably into global and local varieties, and that neither makes a convincing case for a distinctive scientific problem of contrastive underdetermination.In philosophy of science, confirmation holism, also called epistemological holism, is the view that no individual statement can be confirmed or disconfirmed by an empirical test, but only a set of statements (a whole theory).

It is attributed to Willard Van Orman Quine who motivated his holism through extending Pierre Duhem's problem of underdetermination in physical theory to all knowledge.


THE DUHEM THESIS, THE QUINE THESIS AND THE PROBLEM OF MEANING HOLISM IN SCIENTIFIC THEORIES MPhil Thesis by Emiliano Trizio The London School of Economics and Political Science between holism, underdetermination and theory-ladenness of experimentation.

The. Bluescreenofdebt • January 11, AM.

Confirmation holism

This is the 'drive it until it breaks' mentality. Cars with a weird noise can cost hundreds of dollars for something that could have been fixed by using fuel cleaner (a recent experience). Mar 18,  · Duhem, Quine, and Underdetermination The Duhem-Quine thesis is identical to neither the Duhem thesis nor the Quine thesis, [1] which in turn are not identical to one another.

Pierre Duhem (–) was a French physicist and historian and philosopher of science. As a physicist, he championed “energetics,” holding generalized thermodynamics as foundational for physical theory, that is, thinking that all of chemistry and physics, including mechanics, electricity, and magnetism, should be derivable from thermodynamic first principles.

In philosophy of science, confirmation holism, also called epistemological holism, is the view that no individual statement can be confirmed or disconfirmed by an empirical test, but only a .

The duhem-quine thesis and underdetermination
Rated 5/5 based on 11 review